Sermon: Anything wrong with having a favorite beer style?

I read an article recently from Mr. Martyn Cornell who thinks that if you have a favorite style, you don’t like beer.  Here’s the original article, and please go read it before you finish this one:  Is Mr. Cornell wrong? I certainly think so, but I wonder if I’m misunderstanding his point, because the commenters on the post seem to be talking about nothing but English bitter and their dislike of the west coast style of beers.  However, here’s why having a favorite style of beer is no problem at all. 

My favorite style of beer is what is commonly called a scotch ale. It’s generally a rich, malty, relatively high gravity (though it does not have to be) ale brewed with very few hops, and those are primarily light, aromatic varieties. Whatever it is in my personality or tastes that causes me to have a particular fondness for this style, I cannot deny that it hits the spot almost any time I am privileged to have one. It’s like scratching the itch in the center of my back, only it scratches one I didn’t know I had. It’s that first sip of water on a hot day when I didn’t realize just how thirsty I was. It’s easily my favorite style.

So I don’t like beer?  I scoff. I love beer. I love a hefeweizen, with or without a wedge of citrus. I love Pliny the Elder. I love a refreshing Saison. Oh man, I love a rich, dark stout. Lodi Beer Company’s Plowshare porter?  Man, what I wouldn’t do for one right now. I get excited about trying a new beer.  I have driven 2 hours or more just to try a fantastic beer I couldn’t find in stores.  I drove 7-8 hours just to get to Stone Brewing Co. to try beers I couldn’t get up north. I don’t like beer? Ridiculous! What do I have in my fridge right now? Bison’s Organic Chocolate Stout, Buffalo Bill’s Blueberry Oatmeal Stout, a Sam Adams Boston Lager, and a bottle each of Lagunitas Lil’ Sumpin’ Sumpin’ and Lil’ Sumpin’ Wild (for a comparison taste I’m planning). Not a Scotch Ale in the bunch.

So what is it about having a favorite beer style that indicates I don’t like beer? To me, having a favorite beer style doesn’t mean I won’t try something new if it’s available. It doesn’t mean that I drink nothing but Scotch Ales. It doesn’t mean that I buy them by the 6 pack on a weekly basis. What does it mean, then? It means that if I was stranded on a desert island and told I couldn’t have anything but a single style of beer with me, it’d be Scotch Ale. It means that I’m comfortable with it. It’s a flavor profile that I love. It’s comfortable. It’s like coming home from vacation and sleeping in my bed again.

So what about that means I don’t like beer? A ridiculous notion! I’m here to tell you that having a favorite style is not a problem, as long as you don’t pass up the opportunity to try something new. As long as you don’t drink that style to the exclusion of everything else. You can enjoy a favorite style and still love beer.

Now on a different topic, I really want to brew an English Bitter. 3-4% abv, and everything a bitter should be. I’m ON it!

6 thoughts on “Sermon: Anything wrong with having a favorite beer style?

  1. I started out with craft beers in a manner that’s similar to yours.
    Why not have favorite styles or style? Most everyone has a favorite of other things — why not beer.
    Mine – currently is IPA and stouts.


    David Ivey
    Black Bucket Brew Inbox Magazine Editor
    PS. Please check out our free e-book and mag.

  2. I read the original article and I didn’t get it. If you have a favourite beer style then you don’t like beer? Huh? I *usually* prefer dark beers to light beers. Hmm… maybe I should stop drinking beer because I obviously hate the stuff. Maybe he means that if you have a type of beer that you drink to the exclusion of any other beer then you don’t like beer. But that still doesn’t work, because you do like some beer… I’m confused. Good point well made, AE.

    • I’m not sure I get it either, but his statement was very clear. If you have a favorite beer or style, you apparently hate beer. I definitely disagree, as I know very few people who love beers and love trying new beers more than myself, and I definitely have a favorite beer style.

      Regardless, I have no problem with someone having a standby beer, and can still consider them a beer lover. It was, however, a very provocative article, so I thought I’d respond.

  3. Hi I was written a small article/list about all (I hope) beer brands in Iceland today on my blog. How many Icelandic beer brands do you think you can buy in iceland Today ? Have you taste Beer from Iceland ?

    Love and Peace Julius. – Good luck to you.

    • I have to be honest. I’ve never actually heard of an Icelandic beer being available here on the West Coast of the U.S. This is not to say they’re not good. Just that I’ve never seen one available. Do any Icelandic breweries distribute here in the U.S.?

Pull up a stool and join the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s